Skip to main content

Flowers for the New Zealand Film Commission: Fresh Shorts 2011




I love working with Kyna Morgan of Her Film. And from over there in North America, she keeps me in line, often through Twitter. Today, she tweeted about the New Zealand Film Commission’s (NZFC) Fresh Shorts decisions. Fresh Shorts is the NZFC's new low budget short film scheme, run in-house. It aims to identify the next generation of New Zealand feature filmmakers by nurturing and inspiring up-and-coming talent and it has just funded eight films at the $10,000 funding level and eight at $30,000 each. Kyna had been reading OnFilm online and found the NZFC press release. Here's what she wrote:

@devt ur staying up on this, yeah? Looks like gender parity reached for funding. NZFC has no gender mandate, does it? bit.ly/oCRRWT
@HerFilm Actually, I've kinda abandoned it, almost totally fruitless effort-- What's your take on this list? [I was cranky, because I HAD given up, and my mind was elsewhere.]

Kyna didn’t respond. So—of course—I took a look. And she’d done the maths and her addition was correct, so she didn’t need to respond. Women writers and directors are attached to four of the eight green-lit Fresh Shorts projects, at each level.

According to the information on the NZFC website, in 2011—its second year—Fresh Shorts attracted 292 applications, an increase of 68 applications from 2010, 160 applications at the $10,000 funding level and 132 at the $30,000 funding level. The submitted projects conveyed a very diverse range of topics and a wide range of cultural perspectives–reflecting the fresh voices the NZFC hoped the scheme would attract.

A panel from the industry and NZFC staff selected the final sixteen projects: Ainsley Gardiner, Jason Stutter, Peter Salmon, Chris Payne & Kath Akuhata-Brown (NZFC Development Executives) and Lisa Chatfield (NZFC Short Film Manager). This is what Lisa—who was a strong presence at V48Hours, accompanied by a Fresh Shorts video which included a reasonable number of women—said:

The increase in applications this year is a fantastic result for Fresh Shorts and I think relates to a closer connection between Fresh Shorts and V48Hrs this year. Of course it did make the task of choosing just 16 films very challenging! There was plenty of debate amongst the panel and the decisions weren’t all unanimous—the strength of the projects and the film makers involved made the process exciting and challenging.

This year the funded projects include three animations, one documentary and twelve narrative films that range from drama to comedy to horror and are set in the past, the future, the present and even inside cardboard boxes.

The NZFC has supplied no details about the proportion of applications that had women writers and directors attached. If I learn more details, I’ll add them here.

The four short films with women writers and directors that have been green lit at the $30,000 budget level are:
Blankets - Director: Louise Leitch, Writer: Casey Whelan, Producer: Melissa Dodds
Soldier Boy – Writer/Director: Jess Bluck, Producer: Sarah Cook
Taniwha – Writer/Director: Asuka Sylvie, Producers David White & Melissa Dodds
Two Eyes, Two Hands, Two Feet – Director: Kirsten Green, Producer: Stephen Lovatt
The four short films with women writers and directors at the $10,000 budget level are:
Airmail - Writer/Director: Prue Cunningham
Friday Tigers – Writer/Director: Aidee Walker, Producer: Julia Parnell
I’m going to Mum’s – Writer/Director: Lauren Jackson, Producer: Jeremy Macey
Purerehua – Writer/Director: Renae Maihi
Good to see some male producers in there, too, time they invested in more women's stories. Many congratulations to everyone: the writers and directors, the producers, the decision-makers. I'm excited to think that this may lead to a change in the present gendered allocation of feature film funding, which primarily benefits men who are writers and directors.

(And, Kyna, you’re correct again, the NZFC has no gender policy. But New Zealand ratified the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) in 1985. Because of this, the NZFC, like all state agencies must encourage the participation of women in public life on equal terms with men (article 7). It has to consider how to encourage women's access to its state-funded filmmaking programmes, because story-telling on screen is participating in public life. But its track record hasn’t been good, so the flowers are to congratulate them! That doesn’t mean I don’t appreciate your heads up. Again, yet again, my warm thanks to you.)

And this week, the Swedish state film funding gender model is back in the news, in Variety, with a slightly different take than this one, about Swedish women behind the camera, and  Satyen Bordoloi’s last year. Now that’s a great ongoing story!

Comments

  1. Lovely post, Marian, thanks for tackling this so quickly with some great details on things that I still am not up on (might be easier if I were IN New Zealand? maybe not!) My concern is that this type of "happy accident" (or was it?) might not repeat in each funding cycle, wherever it's achieved, in NZ or elsewhere. I love the gender policy, but always hate that we have to legislate and enforce things like that (why can't it just be automatic?) I will continue to think about this and am off to tweet about your post. Thank you for this! Much love and thanks to you as well.

    Best,
    Kyna

    ReplyDelete
  2. While it is so fantastic to see such a strong female presence in this years' greenlit fresh shorts, I wouldn't want it to be 50/50 every time. I would like to think that the NZFC pick the projects purely on which ones are the best.
    Sara

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tx Kyna! And hello & tx to you Sara, too.

    I'm never sure about the 'best' argument, because I think that there are so many ways to define 'best', and Lisa's comment "There was plenty of debate amongst the panel and the decisions weren’t all unanimous" illustrates this, perhaps?

    I imagine that there was a group of strong projects that anyone would take a risk on and invest in, and the panel and individuals in it would have made judgements about various aspects of those projects that reflected their individual and collective tastes and took into account the track records of the applicants (and anyone who advocated for them). And, if the NZFC had twenty strong applications and only 16 projects could be funded, might it not be sensible to say "OK these are all great projects worth risking public money on, so in making a difficult selection, let's make sure we fulfil our obligations under the Treaty of Waitangi, have a gender balance, and ensure that diverse cultures are represented?" (There are of course various other ways of ensuring that this will happen more naturally, by inviting diversity. I think that the NZFC did a good job with that Fresh Shorts clip, though because women don't participate strongly in the V48 Hours, the Fresh Shorts people probably needed to find alternative ways to reach women, some of which I wrote about here: http://wellywoodwoman.blogspot.com/2011/03/media-convergence-mofilm-strategies.html. But who knows, this year women writers and directors may have been attached to as many projects as those with men writers and directors attached.)

    I really love the Swedish way, which I can't find the details of right now, but I remember it as working towards ensuring that the film funding investment in either gender is not less than 40% of the total.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

NZ Update #13: The Brilliance of Molly O'Shea

John O'Shea of Pacific Films is a legend in the film history of Aotearoa New Zealand. He died in 2001, aged 81. His daughter Kathy O'Shea, who died in 2010, was a legendary editor. And his grand-daughter, filmmaker Molly, gave this year's John O'Shea Memorial Address at the annual conference of New Zealand's Screen Production & Development Association (SPADA).

The address would be 'delivered by Dame Jane Campion and special guest', according to the SPADA programme. And what a special guest Molly was.

Her address is an instant feminist classic. Just brilliant. Wherever you live, if you want to persuade someone to give women filmmakers a go, entertain and inform them with this clip.
I hope that some of those producers who gave Molly a standing ovation then seized the opportunity to ask to read her pilot script, described by Jane Campion as 'incredible'. Go Molly! I can't wait to see your work.





Saving Mr. Disney: A Lesbian Perspective By Carolyn Gage

To stay focused when I'm writing intensively, I go to the movies in the afternoons. It's a kind of meditation that includes the walk down the hill to the cinema and back up again afterwards. And a few weeks ago, I saw three women-directed movies in three days: Rama Burshtein's Fill The Void, Anaïs Barbeau-Lavalette's Inch'Allah and Nicole Holofcener's Enough Said. Maybe things have changed, I thought to myself, ever optimistic. But I also noticed that men wrote and directed Catching Fire, from a novel by a woman, about a young woman and produced by a woman. And then I read Vocativ's analysis of 2013's 50 top-grossing US releases. This shows that almost half were Bechdel Test-passing films and that they did better at the US box office than those that weren't. BUT except for Frozen, which Jennifer Lee co-directed (and wrote) men directed all 50. And then at the weekend, all three of the new releases reviewed in our local paper (with enthusiasm) told s…

NZ Update #3: WIFT New Zealand

This is Part 3 of an NZ Update 4-part series. Part 1 was Gender Breakthrough in New Zealand Film Commission Funding. Part 2 was a letter to Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Women, Paula Bennett, about the New Zealand Screen Production Grant. Part 4 is a not-quite-A-Z of New Zealand women directors and some writers.

So how has Women in Film & Television New Zealand (WIFTNZ) responded to the lack of gender parity between women and men who write and direct, in particular the lack of gender parity in allocation of taxpayer funding? For example, does it endorse Telefilm Canada's statement, referred to back in Part 1 and to some extent implicit in the New Zealand Film Commission (NZFC)'s latest Annual Report?–
Based on industry recommendations that these two roles require immediate critical attention, gender parity amongst directors and screenwriters was identified as a priority (emphasis added).The simple answer: No-one Knows For Sure. And because of this, I believe it'…